All the Pope’s Men: Vatican Diplomacy & Espionage in Elizabethan England
Pope Pius V’s promulgation of the bull Regnans in Excelsis, excommunicating Queen Elizabeth I of England, was a drastic course of action exacerbated preexisting tensions between recusant Catholics and the established regime and ushered in a new chapter in the diplomatic struggle between the Holy See and England. A result of the bull was a marginalization of English Catholics, painted as loyal to a foreign power before their mother country. Catholic operatives reacted to this marginalization in two different ways. First, they launched attempts to depose Elizabeth. These efforts were led by prominent individuals, such as Thomas Howard, 4th Duke of Norfolk, and did little to dispense with popular notions of Catholic disloyalty. Second, were efforts to provide spiritual sustenance to recusant Catholics, which were led by Jesuit priests such as Edmund Campion, S.J., who were smuggled into the country to offer the Sacraments and counter official efforts to suppress Catholicism. These efforts, and those who participated in them, placed less of an emphasis on political objectives and instead focused on aiding the suffering Church. These two spheres, and their interactions with the Elizabethan intelligence services, produced a unique geopolitical situation. This poster provides a brief introduction to the key historical circumstances and figures of the period, the research goals of this project, and its preliminary findings and conclusions.
Comments
During the efforts of the…
During the efforts of the Holy See to subvert Elizabethan rule and bring back a Catholic monarch to the throne, was there any coordinated attempts between the Pope and Catholic states such as that of Phillip II of Habsburg Spain to attack England? How much of a significant role did the Holy See play in this agreement if there was one to begin with?
Winners write history?
This is a fascinating project, and I especially appreciate the perspective you are taking here. After all, these Catholic agents and British Catholics more broadly didn't know that the Protestant monarchy in England was going to prevail, any more than Elizabeth herself did. It makes me think about the accidental and contingent in history--and the fact that we interpret Catholic espionage efforts through the later lens of their ultimate failure. Good on you for seeking to recapture the stakes of the moment, and the fundamental uncertainty about how it was going to turn out!
Cam Grey
Department of Classical Studies
Faculty Director, Lauder College House