The Bidirectional Relationship between Sleep and Externalizing Behavior: A Systematic Review
The aim of this project was to review and analyze the available studies on the bidirectional nature of sleep (sleep duration, sleep quality, sleep/wake problems, insomnia) and externalizing behavior (aggression, hyperactivity, delinquency, impulsivity, attentional problems). We aim to provide initial answers to the following research questions: Does externalizing behavior cause sleep problems? Do sleep problems cause externalizing behavior? Or is the relationship reciprocal, with sleep problems predisposing to externalizing behavior which then feeds into further sleep problems? Alternatively, is any bidirectional relationship confounded by other factors? Furthermore, do different sleep measures (objective vs subjective vs a combination of both) influence study outcomes? What are potential mechanisms governing this association? Finally, what are the limitations of existing studies, and how may these gaps be addressed in future research?
Gaining more insights into reciprocal links between sleep and externalizing behavior is of potential importance to clinical practice in that both sleep and behavioral symptoms, rather than one but not the other, may be targeted in therapy to effectively tackle a self-perpetuating deleterious sleep-mental health cycle. We posit that this finding might be particularly beneficial for subclinical populations struggling with sleep and/or behavioral problems: breaking their cycle with such a two-pronged therapeutic approach at early stages of the impairment can prevent more severe clinical health problems from emerging.
Comments
Very Clear, Organized, and Impactful
The presentation of this review is very clear and organized. I especially like the provided definitions for "bidirectionality" and "externalizing behavior." Since these are two key features of the study, it was quite helpful to include specific definitions for each. The "Mechanisms" figures also helped me to understand the bidirectionality between sleep problems and externalizing behavior. Overall, the "Conclusion" section is the most impactful since it went beyond the review and into everyday life.
Fascinating yet intuitive bidirectionality!
I enjoy the relevance of your work to our everyday lives, especially as a student who cares about sleeping and its effects on the different systems you examined. Great poster, Jan!